Since childhood, five friends regularly catch and retain this tradition as adults in this tradition. Even after 30 years, they meet every May, even to maintain their friendship. Ironically, Jerry Pierce (Jeremy Renner), who is undefeated so far, wants to marry and thus probably falls out of the future as a teammate. He’s always too fast for the others, ready for anything and good for acrobatic stakes, but this year his friends finally want to catch him.
Especially his buddy Hoagie (Ed Helms) is eager to beat Jerry after all this time, and journalist Rebecca Crosby (Annabelle Wallis) is curious if that will work.